As well is two words!
How does a sage know everything about everything? or does he? or does he just think he does?
Remember, if you buy something you bought it, not brought it.
Well i have a 2012 Seat Alea XL SE TDI DSG (7Speed) and it will tow 1500KG my mate got a Seat Altea XL SE 2.0 TDI Manual and that will only pull 1400KG we think this is weird ....
As well is two words!
How does a sage know everything about everything? or does he? or does he just think he does?
Remember, if you buy something you bought it, not brought it.
I tow with a Chrysler 300C Touring and is only the 2nd automatic I've owned. The 1st one was a Fiat 132 about 25 years ago which was a totally different ballgame. The Chrysler is an effortless towcar and I wouldn't go back to manual !.
However the handbook recommends that to save straining the gearbox it be used as a manual when towing and has a quick select option like a paddle gearbox to make it easier. I just flick the gear lever to the left to go down and to the right to go up - easy peasy !
I wonder if it depends on if the manufacturer thought many owners would want to buy one in order to tow?
Does the ones you have been looking at have gearbox oil coolers fitted as standard, I know with the Rangie, there is no difference in the tow limit from manual to auto but the autos have oil coolers fitted as standard.
This question comes up quite regular the the answer is always the same, most answers are in favour of the modern Auto.
My last 2 cars have been auto and i would never go back to manual.
I have towed with two Sorento automatics over the past 6 years and had I continued towing without doubt the next car would have also been auto. Have just changed to a motorhome which unfortunately did not have an auto as an option.
Re the towing limits on the ones we abloom ing at tending to be lower on the auto versions does this actually make any difference to the driving overall, or how the car can handle the towing of the caravan. For example if the caravan is 1800kg and the car tow limit was 2000kg on the auto model and 2500kg on the ,annual model, assuming the kerbweihts are pretty much the same to give a good car/van tow ratio would the automatic with a lower(but adequate) for your van still be the better choice?
I hope that makes sense?? Only up until now ve been looking at as higher tow limit as possible, but is that really so necessary if kerbweights etc mean its fine to tow
Will never go back to a manual for towing. The auto box combined with cruise control makes for really effortless towing, particularly the long distance stuff.
An auto is always easier, whether towing or solo, some autos will have a lower towing weight, worse fuel consumption and higher emissions hence VED.some the same. You have to do the research on vehicles within your budget
We tow with a manual X Trail, I did consider the auto ( we towed with a Q7 auto last year on one trip and it was a dream). However the Q7 was new and borrowed from work. The X trail auto is less powerfull than the manual and has higher running costs (emissions etc) so we went for manual. This isnt the case with every car but you should consider this when choosing as you won't be towing every day.
But money no object or if running costs the same I would be tempted to go with an auto next time.
I tow with a Chrysler 300c tourer which has the slush box and its an absolute dream, get on the motorways, stick on the cruise and sit back and enjoy the view, a lot less stressfull than towing with a manual.
Quote: Originally posted by nitnat on 11/4/2013
... but most of them have lower towing capacities than their manual versions!
The brochure for the MK5 VW Golf specifies exactly the same towing capacity for a DSG Automatic box as for a manual version when pulling a braked trailer, and a slightly HIGHER capacity for the DSG over the manual if the trailer is unbraked.