Hi just come back from maiden caravanning trip and all went well apart from the smell of the clutch when reversing on to pitch. Is this normal and if so how long will my clutch actually last.
Cheers
Not long if your slipping it or its struggling to reverse the van.
Are the brakes releasing cleanly when reversing?
I bought my last car with a fairly high clutch pedal. Thought it will need one of those sooner rather than later. But 4 years later it was still the same.
I doubt i would be saying the same if i had not fitted the motor mover.
And typically 3 months or so after fitting the mover the caravan storage changed its layout and i now have the room to reverse it in.
Oh well. I still use the mover. Saves on clutches.
Hi have got a motor mover but the problem was actually reversing back at the farm, Motor mover wouldn't move it because of it being to muddy. Think i will invest in some crusher to level my spot ? I also read that the smell is more common when reversing with a 4x4 diesel car.
Thanks
Much depends on the torque output of the towing vehicle as a vehicle with a low BHP will normally have a lower torque ratio and often a smaller diameter clutch which contributes to more slipping of the clutch plate constantly spinning against the flywheel without any grip thus creating the burning smell. This will shorten the life of the clutch if it continues on a regular basis but a vehicle with a higher BHP and torque delivery will obviously push the caravan backwards more easily thus causing less clutch wear with no burning smell. I had identical clutch burning problems when reversing my caravan with a 1.8 ltr. petrol Zafira and a 1.6 ltr. diesel Focus but never had a problem with my 2.0 ltr. diesel Focus or my current 2.4 ltr. diesel Volvo because the latter are considered more of a work horse in terms of clutch size and torque delivery. So generally there's nothing to be concerned about regarding the clutch burning smell as this is quite the norm with under powered towing vehicles. Basically that's one of the reasons why they never install less than a 2.0 ltr. engine into a motorhome engine bay because anything smaller wouldn't be up to the job.
Quote: Originally posted by Greendemon315 on 10/2/2014
It only happens when you have your foot, on the clutch. You need to be sure to step right off it as soon as you are moving.
Jim
In the nine years I owned a little Skoda felicia 1.6 74bhp 101 lbs I never had any problems with towing or reversing no smelly clutch what so ever and we towed from Norfolk to Scotland every year sometimes twice, when I sold the car we estimated we had towed in the region of thirty thousand miles and the car still had plenty of life left in it. In all we put 120000 miles on the clock traveling to all four corners of the country without any problems at all, so to my mind it's all down to how you drive ie keep your foot off the clutch pedal as much as you can.
Its nto more common with a diesel car. Quite the opposite in fact.
A diesel car will have more low down torque than a petrol car. So you can take your foot off the clutch at a little over tickover speed with a diesel where a petrol car may require more revs.
You need to use a few revs as possible. And not slip the clutch.
You motor mover should cope with mud. Going back a few years we were camped near Bude in Cornwall. It rained constantly. Massive hill behind the campsite and ran down to a small stream at the bottom.
My caravan sank upto the depth of the tyres sidewalls over the week. The movers had no problem pulling the van out and onto the driveway.
Tommo799 - In answer to your question, I have experienced a similar problem with a burning clutch when reversing a caravan with a Focus 1.6 diesel.
I towed my new caravan from the sales centre back to my house with no problems. My clutch started to burn when reversing the caravan onto my property. It took nearly a week for the burning smell to disappear. The clutch seemed to be fine with normal motoring (minus caravan). My first trip with the caravan was towing it from Spain to the UK, some 1500 miles! All the way back, my thoughts were with the burning clutch, but we arrived in the UK with no problems.
I decided to store the caravan in the UK, instead of towing it back to Spain. Needless to say, the car did the reverse trip of 1500 miles, again with no problems.
My car has just completed 60,000 miles so the clutch has already been well used.
Hope my experience gives you more confidence with your clutch
Quote: Originally posted by Grampian91 on 10/2/2014Its nto more common with a diesel car. Quite the opposite in fact.
A diesel car will have more low down torque than a petrol car. So you can take your foot off the clutch at a little over tickover speed with a diesel where a petrol car may require more revs.
You need to use a few revs as possible. And not slip the clutch.
You motor mover should cope with mud. Going back a few years we were camped near Bude in Cornwall. It rained constantly. Massive hill behind the campsite and ran down to a small stream at the bottom.
My caravan sank upto the depth of the tyres sidewalls over the week. The movers had no problem pulling the van out and onto the driveway.
Believe me the mover wouldn't pull it out, One wheel had sunk and the other hadn't the van was just spinning. You must have a super mover.
Quote: Originally posted by Spanish5 on 10/2/2014
Tommo799 - In answer to your question, I have experienced a similar problem with a burning clutch when reversing a caravan with a Focus 1.6 diesel.
I towed my new caravan from the sales centre back to my house with no problems. My clutch started to burn when reversing the caravan onto my property. It took nearly a week for the burning smell to disappear. The clutch seemed to be fine with normal motoring (minus caravan). My first trip with the caravan was towing it from Spain to the UK, some 1500 miles! All the way back, my thoughts were with the burning clutch, but we arrived in the UK with no problems.
I decided to store the caravan in the UK, instead of towing it back to Spain. Needless to say, the car did the reverse trip of 1500 miles, again with no problems.
My car has just completed 60,000 miles so the clutch has already been well used.
Hope my experience gives you more confidence with your clutch