Home Log in or Register

Message Forums

Welcome Guest

Reception - All Forums

Caravans and Caravanning - Caravan Towcars and Towing Advice

Topic: Automatic or manual

Page: 1 2 3 4

billyboggins

29/3/2017 at 1:32am
Location: norfolk
Outfit: Bailey Pageant Burgundy 6 volvo V70

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 23/2/2010

Gold Member

Forum Posts: 425

Site Reviews Total:	11

Site Reviews 2024:	2
Site Reviews 2023:	1
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	3
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	1
Site Reviews 2018:	1

Site Nights 2024:	7
Site Nights 2023:	7
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	15
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	8
Site Nights 2018:	1

i will NEVER buy a manual again either towing or otherwise,,what's the point ..towing with an auto box is a breeze

-------------
billyboggins

billyboggins

29/3/2017 at 1:35am
Location: norfolk
Outfit: Bailey Pageant Burgundy 6 volvo V70

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 23/2/2010

Gold Member

Forum Posts: 425

Site Reviews Total:	11

Site Reviews 2024:	2
Site Reviews 2023:	1
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	3
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	1
Site Reviews 2018:	1

Site Nights 2024:	7
Site Nights 2023:	7
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	15
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	8
Site Nights 2018:	1

Excellent post Mike

-------------
billyboggins

Mike3003

29/3/2017 at 10:26am
Location:
Outfit:

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 15/7/2013

Platinum Member

Forum Posts: 1455

Site Reviews Total:	1

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

Quote: Originally posted by billyboggins on 29/3/2017
Excellent post Mike

😀👍👍

-------------
Not ALL Newts get p**sed.

“Semper Fidelis”

keith p

29/3/2017 at 6:45pm
Location: None Entered
Outfit: None Entered

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 09/4/2016

Standard Member

Forum Posts: 20

Site Reviews Total:	0

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

Hi, I have a Skoda with a seven speed DSG automatic gearbox and it is brilliant. Ideal for towing with hill start and can be used as a standard auto or you can change gear manually. This a well proven reliable gearbox used on a wide range of vehicles and capable of high torque loads. A big improvement on the old torque converter autos.

misterg

29/3/2017 at 7:30pm
Location: East Midlands
Outfit: Coachman VIP 575.Santa Fe

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 09/12/2003

Diamond Member

Forum Posts: 1538

Site Reviews Total:	2

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

I bit the bullet as a try out on auto. It was great for towing as many above have said. I have had 2 auto since and would not use manual again for towing.My wife has an old manual which is fine but auto always for towing. I

-------------
Mister G

freeatlast

29/3/2017 at 7:31pm
Location: Teesside
Outfit: Mitsubishi ASX4

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 23/3/2008

Diamond Member

Forum Posts: 2135

Site Reviews Total:	2

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

Quote: Originally posted by keith p on 29/3/2017
Hi, I have a Skoda with a seven speed DSG automatic gearbox and it is brilliant. Ideal for towing with hill start and can be used as a standard auto or you can change gear manually. This a well proven reliable gearbox used on a wide range of vehicles and capable of high torque loads. A big improvement on the old torque converter autos.

What's better about it than a decent torque converter box? I can use mine as a standard auto or use the paddle shifts. It automatically adjusts to cope with towing, and thus the paddle shifts are never needed in practice.

Colin21

29/3/2017 at 7:51pm
Location: East Herts
Outfit: 1992 Elddis Wisp 450CT + X Trail

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 05/11/2013

Diamond Member

Forum Posts: 6270

Site Reviews Total:	18

Site Reviews 2024:	1
Site Reviews 2023:	1
Site Reviews 2022:	2
Site Reviews 2021:	2
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	2
Site Reviews 2018:	3

Site Nights 2024:	7
Site Nights 2023:	8
Site Nights 2022:	12
Site Nights 2021:	18
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	21
Site Nights 2018:	18

Quote: Originally posted by freeatlast on 29/3/2017

Quote: Originally posted by keith p on 29/3/2017
Hi, I have a Skoda with a seven speed DSG automatic gearbox and it is brilliant. Ideal for towing with hill start and can be used as a standard auto or you can change gear manually. This a well proven reliable gearbox used on a wide range of vehicles and capable of high torque loads. A big improvement on the old torque converter autos.

What's better about it than a decent torque converter box? I can use mine as a standard auto or use the paddle shifts. It automatically adjusts to cope with towing, and thus the paddle shifts are never needed in practice.

I'm sure both types have their advantages and disadvantages. In all probability its a matter of personal preference. As a long-term user of TC autos, I would question the need for so many gears with DSG. The 4 gears in my auto-box are more than adequate, as the converter gives a range of ratios within each gear. However, I accept that DSG gearboxes are reputedly more economical.

-------------
Best Regards,
Colin

keith p

29/3/2017 at 8:00pm
Location: None Entered
Outfit: None Entered

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 09/4/2016

Standard Member

Forum Posts: 20

Site Reviews Total:	0

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

Hi,
The DSG auto is far more efficient than the Torque Converter autos which generate a lot of heat through the fluid drive which in turn leads to poorer fuel consumption. Towing with a torque converter box may require the fitment of a gearbox heat exchanger.

Colin21

29/3/2017 at 8:14pm
Location: East Herts
Outfit: 1992 Elddis Wisp 450CT + X Trail

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 05/11/2013

Diamond Member

Forum Posts: 6270

Site Reviews Total:	18

Site Reviews 2024:	1
Site Reviews 2023:	1
Site Reviews 2022:	2
Site Reviews 2021:	2
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	2
Site Reviews 2018:	3

Site Nights 2024:	7
Site Nights 2023:	8
Site Nights 2022:	12
Site Nights 2021:	18
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	21
Site Nights 2018:	18

Quote: Originally posted by keith p on 29/3/2017
Hi,
The DSG auto is far more efficient than the Torque Converter autos which generate a lot of heat through the fluid drive which in turn leads to poorer fuel consumption. Towing with a torque converter box may require the fitment of a gearbox heat exchanger.

True to some extent Keith, but largely outdated. Some TC boxes may (as you say) require a heat exchanger for towing, but many like my Volvo are already so fitted.

Many years ago I used to tow with a Mk 2 Cortina. At times I towed a large trailer on which I often had cars larger than the Cortina. Before doing so I contacted Borg Warner, who made my gearbox, and asked for their advice about fitting a cooler to the gearbox. They advised instead that I fit a temperature gauge to the box, which I did, and they told me to stop for a break if the temperature exceeded a certain point, which it never did. That was a car built in 1966, with a 3 speed auto.

My Volvo does 40mpg solo, around town, and 50mpg solo on a run. Towing makes little difference to that, but my caravan isn't particularly big or heavy. Not bad though for a 17 year old car weighing nearly 2 tons. Would it do that much better with a DSG box?

-------------
Best Regards,
Colin

Mike3003

30/3/2017 at 9:11am
Location:
Outfit:

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 15/7/2013

Platinum Member

Forum Posts: 1455

Site Reviews Total:	1

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

Quote: Originally posted by freeatlast on 29/3/2017

Quote: Originally posted by keith p on 29/3/2017
Hi, I have a Skoda with a seven speed DSG automatic gearbox and it is brilliant. Ideal for towing with hill start and can be used as a standard auto or you can change gear manually. This a well proven reliable gearbox used on a wide range of vehicles and capable of high torque loads. A big improvement on the old torque converter autos.

What's better about it than a decent torque converter box? I can use mine as a standard auto or use the paddle shifts. It automatically adjusts to cope with towing, and thus the paddle shifts are never needed in practice.

It does nothing a DSG does not do! Everything you have described is done by a DSG box. Again, I cannot understand why those with TC boxes do not realise the DSG does all those things, plus hill decent control. I would have no issue with a TC box, but I am much more than happy with the DSG. Progress is a wonderful thing. 😀👍

-------------
Not ALL Newts get p**sed.

“Semper Fidelis”

Speedway

30/3/2017 at 1:12pm
Location: Norwich Norfolk UK
Outfit: Lunar Lexon 420 & Nissan Qashqai+2

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 04/9/2013

Standard Member

Forum Posts: 15

Site Reviews Total:	3

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	1
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	3
Site Nights 2018:	0

There are several types of "automatic" gearboxes available now and all have advantages and disadvantages. I have a Nissan Qashqai with the Torque convertor type and have found it fine for towing and solo. 6 speeds, the ability to flip it across to manual mode and choose my own gears which is ideal for engine braking down a hill, or when I want to hold it in a lower gear for overtaking. I accept that the twin clutch gearboxes are more economical though,and very popular, but I bet they will never be as reliable as the torque convertor type. Both the DSG and Ford Powershift are twin clutch gearboxes and are not without their faults. Search Google or Honest John and you will find numerous stories of the gearboxes getting confused if you slow at a junction or roundabout then hit the throttle to pull away quickly and they choose the wrong gear. I believe the powershift gearbox had so many problems in its early days it was the subject of lawsuits in both the USA and Australia as not being fit for purpose! Ford brought out lots of mods and software updates and hopefully they have got it right now. My Brother had a DSG in a VW Golf and it jammed in 1st gear and had to be transported to a VW garage to sort it. This was on a new car! Because the DSG and Powershift are basically two manual clutches, they also have two clutch plates which will wear eventually and other bits like dual mass flywheels to absorb the torque shock. These will also wear and eventually need replacing just as in a manual box. There is an interesting article on the Honest John web site about this;
http://www.honestjohn.co.uk/askhj/answer/27427/does-my-volkswagen-passat-dsg-have-a-dual-mass-flywheel-
To summarise, you pay your money and take your choice, and I haven't even mentioned the boom in CVT transmissions. Thats for another day!

Colin21

30/3/2017 at 7:25pm
Location: East Herts
Outfit: 1992 Elddis Wisp 450CT + X Trail

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 05/11/2013

Diamond Member

Forum Posts: 6270

Site Reviews Total:	18

Site Reviews 2024:	1
Site Reviews 2023:	1
Site Reviews 2022:	2
Site Reviews 2021:	2
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	2
Site Reviews 2018:	3

Site Nights 2024:	7
Site Nights 2023:	8
Site Nights 2022:	12
Site Nights 2021:	18
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	21
Site Nights 2018:	18

Mike3003, I can think of one thing that a TC box does that a DSG doesn't, and that is the torque doubling through the torque converter. The infinitely variable ratio of the torque converter (usually up to 2 - 1) means that a TC box doesn't need so many gears, and when needed provides an overall ratio of half of first gear.

I'm sure that a DSG box has other advantages, but in my opinion neither is overall "better" than the other. They are just different, and which we prefer is a matter of personal choice.

The TC box has certainly been around an awful lot longer, and has therefore had more of its "bugs" ironed out.

-------------
Best Regards,
Colin

Mike3003

30/3/2017 at 10:29pm
Location:
Outfit:

View Profile

Quote

Joined: 15/7/2013

Platinum Member

Forum Posts: 1455

Site Reviews Total:	1

Site Reviews 2024:	0
Site Reviews 2023:	0
Site Reviews 2022:	0
Site Reviews 2021:	0
Site Reviews 2020:	0
Site Reviews 2019:	0
Site Reviews 2018:	0

Site Nights 2024:	0
Site Nights 2023:	0
Site Nights 2022:	0
Site Nights 2021:	0
Site Nights 2020:	0
Site Nights 2019:	0
Site Nights 2018:	0

Quote: Originally posted by Colin21 on 30/3

I'm sure that a DSG box has other advantages, but in my opinion neither is overall "better" than the other. They are just different, and which we prefer is a matter of personal choice

g

That Colin, is exactly my point. Well said.

Mike

-------------
Not ALL Newts get p**sed.

“Semper Fidelis”

In order to post a reply you will need to register, or if already registered please log in here

Prev Next
Jump To Page: 1 2 3 4
Quick Links - All Forums - Caravan Towcars and Towing Advice - Top of Page

Printable version

Latest News, Discounts and Competitions see all...

9752 Visitors online !

Free UKCampsite.co.uk Window Sticker - Recommend to Friend - Add a Missing Campsite

[Message Forums] [Caravan Sites & Camping] [Company Listings] [Features / Advice] [Virtual Brochure] [Shop!]
[Reception] [Competitions] [Caravans & Motorhomes For Sale] [Event Diary] [Contact Us] [Tent Reviews]

Please note we are not responsible for the content of external sites & any reviews represent the author's personal view only. Please report any error here. You may view our privacy and cookie policy and terms and conditions here. All copyrights & other intellectual property rights in the design and content of this web site are reserved to the UKCampsite.co.uk © 1999 - 2024

UKCampsite.co.uk
2024 Advent Calendar

24 Daily Prizes PLUS a Christmas Day Star Prize worth £999

Request a Reminder