Message Forums

Tried them both and prefere airbed BUT only if its a ocleman double comfort !

The left and right chambers are seperate and htey are soo comfy and ultra reliable ( when you get a good one ! 1st one had a leak from new but second one has been going for years with no probs )

I have  a really bad back and have sometime got the coleman out to sleep on at home

Its personal choice. We have always used thermarest self inflating mattresses which are 100% comfy, mimimum effort and warm. 

Others swear by airbeds, but the thermarests suit us so well I have never had any motivation to try them. All that faffing about with insulating the bag of cold air, which an airbed is , underneath, on top , three times over  sounds like way too much hard work and stuff to pack to me! MT

I'm not keen on airbeds: I never sleep very well on them even if I'm not sharing, if sharing then its even worse! Having said that, I've not tried one of the more expensive double-chamber ones, but I can't see it suiting me because its still an airbed. We use two fat airics with a double fitted sheet to hold them together - this works really well and even if you end up laying on the join they don't move apart at all. I find them as comfortable as my bed at home (each person can customise the firmness to their own ideal) and they're nice and warm too - I'd never go back to an airbed now! I wish I'd known about them years ago as they're much lighter to carry than a deflated airbed (tho they do take up slightly more room).

I think that this is one of those things that there isn't a definitive answer: its all a matter of personal preference.

My first post! hello!!

Those fat airics look fantastic for a big girl like me. We've got a water bed, so no chance of replicating that on a camp site! Haven't actually been yet, it's been too wet since we got our tent 3 weeks ago, and for the first time I'd rather put the tent up in the dry!

We're going to use a normal airbed the first time as we have already got one, but I think this is the thing that could potentially put me off camping, so if I can't sleep on that, we'll go for the fat airics - or at least I will!

Lorna

Had 5 coleman airbeds in last 3 years. Got sick of them going down every other day, not to mentions punctures etc.

Went to air mat and much better. 

Used to have airbeds ; but seemed to constantly be pumping them up ! We even ended up leaving 4 single ones at the camp site once as they went down all the time , and they weren't cheap !

 Also found they took too much room up in the car and were quite heavy ( I now have a small car ) so we're on self inflating mats and foam mats . Much more comfortable for us , warmer and more reliable