We have just returned from our first trip with the montana 6 (previously had the hartford xl) and all 5 of us were very pleased with the tent and the space inside. I did however have a problem with the poles. When trying to pull the poles apart, most were hard, but one section i couldnt pull apart. (I must admit that when the tent was erected the roof poles seemed sloppy) The pole had moved to such a degree in the socket that it had stuck the two sections together, mind you it was very windy. The place i brought it from said they would look at the poles and today swapped the poles for the brown poles which i have been told are heavy gauge than this years poles (and were the replacements for last years model)
I was just wondering if anyone else have the problem with sloppy poles and if anyone could offer any advise on the brown poles!
Also had a few problems pitching the tent, getting pins into base of poles, SIG to taught! and trying to lift the poles after pegging the end section.
The pole problem is extremely common. The poles twist slightly so making it hard to seperate them. The best way to do it is to tap the joint where it is stuck with a mallett. After a couple of taps it will loosen and you will be able to pull it apart.
Don't pull too hard, the metal wire that links the poles together has a habit of moving. If this happens, the best way to get it back into position is to get a thin fibreglass pole from your local camping shop and push that down into the metal pole and tap it with the mallett until it is back where it should be. I am not sure that Outwell have made the best job possible in the design of these poles. They certainly do their job and are extremely strong, but can be a pain sometimes.
The brown poles were for last year's model. Last year there were initial problems with the 2005 Monty poles. The original poles were silver and kept splitting ( not all, but a lot of them ). Outwell recalled all the poles and replaced them. The replacement poles were brown and weighed substantially more than the original poles. The new Monty 2006 came with the modified poles but they were back to silver again. But they are basically the same as the brown poles of last year. But having said that, the brown poles last year didn't twist so I guess had a slightly better design where the pole sections meet. There is no reason why last year's poles shouldn't fit this year's model as the dimensions are the same. In strength, they are no different though.
The brown poles that i have been given, like Lanleys says are the same dimensions, although they look a slighty smaller diameter that the original poles. I did ask the question regarding the side clips, apparently the clips will be ok as they are tight on the original poles. (Hope hes right)
The brown poles definately seem a better fit than the original poles, alot less movement when joined together.
On the brown poles, each section is shorter that the poles that came with the tent. What i mean by that is that the roof pole on the brown poles is made in 5 sections, where as the original poles were made in 4. Side poles are the same. Net result is that the carry bag is now shorter and fatter!
We bought the Monty 6 at the end of last season and it came with the brownish coloured Poles. Until reading the comments on here I wasn't aware that these were replacements due to a recall on earlier 2005 poles.
Any way I have to say that we have had no issues at all with the poles, they are strong and go together and pull apart with ease.
As far as putting up the tent we usually do this in about 20mins by putting in all the poles first. Peg the back outer corners of ground sheet. Then working from the back put the pins in the back poles, lift up and then support by pegging the two rear guide ropes. Then just lift each set of poles in turn working from the back. When they are all up, support the front with guide ropes. You can then stretch everything out and peg down and reposition the guide ropes on the front and rear if needed.
Hope this helps.
We are just about to leave for Devon to do a bit of surfing and sunbathing.
Last year's poles were fine. I never had to tap mine. I am not sure what they have done this year. It seems as though they changed the shape of the holes and this allows the poles to twist a little. It doesn't cause a problem if you know about it, but I definitiely prefered last years poles.
The poles that came with the tent allowed the pole to twist quite abit, i would guess that it could have been upto as much as 30deg!
So hoping that these ones are better, definately look it. Might be being a bit of a worrier now, but hope the tent looks ok with the brown poles! as have only seen it with the silver ones!