I can't help but ask this question , I know a lot of you out there have polycotton tents and i know they are warmer at night and cooler in the day , I also know that if looked after they last longer (not that i agree with that as i have had a polyester tent for 10yrs and it's still going strong).
So how come Outwell has the Avantgarde range as its flagship brand and not the BL WL and the likes , am i just being thick here but i just don't get it .
If its just a marketing ploy to appeal to the masses i don't get that either as tents like the marywell are just as expensive as some of the BL's etc etc , So why not market them as the flagship models.
Don't forget to leave a review of all tents you've used, for a chance to win fantastic prizes
i dunno its horses for courses. Polys are similar to canvasin the way it weathers and acts, but have a more "modern" design.
Canvas is similar properties, but a more 70's feel.
I think all tents incuding synthetics are good, but you have to realise that with polycottons and canvas, there is a lot more work involved in maintaining it.
I think its horses for courses, but no reason why you cannot have different tents for different purposes.... I consider polycottons and canvas for hotter and colder aweather and synthetics for rainier weather (mainly because it dries quicker), but as i say its horses for courses :-)
------------- Camped since 2008 and still loving it!
With so many Canvas types around it is a tough call, just depends on what you want the tent for, take Cabanon for instance, the model I have you can get in either Polyester (Rip-Stop Nylon) or "All Season Polyester" (not Polycotton) and Cotton Canvas, Cabanon don't have a Polycotton offering, no Canvas type could be described as the best, to cover all bases you need to have variety of tents, we have six tents now including the two Utility tent's, and I am still thinking about another!.
I have been camping for over 45 years uurgh feels old. Anyway when i started camping polyester tents did not exist. It was a major discovery at the time for hikers due to the light weight and probably cheapness of the material. How ever it became apparent that it had negative sides including condensation forming on the inside of the tent and dripping, little or no ventilation, hardly any shade is created and noisier than cotton tents in the rain. Polyester tents are still great for hiking but not for large family tents. Weight seems hardly an issue when most people turn up with MPV's, roof boxes and or trailers.It seems to me that alot of the cost of a tent is surely in the man hours taken to stich it together so the material is hardly the issue. So then why, here in the uk, have we a massive choice of polyester tents and hardly any choice of polycotton tents. PROFIT. Its more profitable to sell polyester tents than polycotton tents. We the british public are easily persuaded as we only buy whats on offer. We are not very demanding consumers. Therefore all the tent retailers sell a majority of polyester tents. If you want choice start to look on at the Dutch retailers they have an amazing choice of cotton tents. I have just bought a HYPER CAMP cotton tunnel tent from a company called
http://www.obelink.nl/ws/home.asp
We received it today after ordering it 4 days ago over the internet. We have just had it up in the garden and its a brilliant quality for less than half the price of a poly cotton tent in the uk. We are still so cynical about the so called recession and retailers being greedy. It still seems to be rip off Britain to me. If you want cotton go Dutch.
Don't forget to leave a review of all tents you've used, for a chance to win fantastic prizes
Cottontent, (have we met before?) well said ... especially the thumbs up for Obelink, very professional company with top quality gear.
Horses for course is very true. There is no perfect tent, just ones preferences.
I own a small 2 man, nylon Salewa tent that is great for backpacking/cycle touring. Bought in 1993 and still going strong.
However for multi night stays with a family ... in Mediterranean sunshine, I use Dutch cotton Canvas.
The best tent is the one that works for you in any given situation, that's why we need more than just one tent .... a lot more than just one!
Cottontent, we did consider polycotton, but I much prefer our synthetic tents for the camping we mostly do - which is camping in the UK, where it is likley to rain pretty often.