Message Forums

I'm not familiar with either tent, both seem to have pros and cons.

The Gelert has a higher HH (although that means nothing if its not been taken care of - it makes no difference how tightly woven the material is, if the seams are shot or the material damaged you'll get wet!!), its a more practical size to erect, the living area looks ok - although you might struggle to get 5 people and a dog sitting in comfort.  Remember that the bigger sleeping area needs more heating, if just the three of you go and your daughter sleeps alone in one pod, she might find its a bit chilly.

The Easy Camp is 7m long by the looks of things, that might make it more troublesome to erect.  You do get a better living area and I don't think the smaller sleeping pods would be a huge issue.

Both erect inner first, which if you know what you're doing and can get the tent up quickly between rain showers won't be a problem.  But it is something to bear in mind as some people don't like this.

Hope thats been some help.  If it was me I'd probably plump for the Gelert out of the two, depending on its condition.