I haven't posted much here before but do lurk and use the campsite search.
At the end of last summer hols we were at Nantcol having a fab time until it started to rain, it rained for around 12 hours solid and the ground was saturated.
Sadly my previously reliable SIG started to leak, is this normal and would a footprint have helped or should I just use extra groundsheets inside which can be removed and dried when its not raining?
Hope someone has some advice as I can't afford to replace the tent at the moment but don't want to stop camping obviously.
Don't forget to leave a review of all tents you've used, for a chance to win fantastic prizes
Yes the rest of the tent was dry, it mainly leaked by the door where people were coming in and out but it has a porch so not from wet boots or coats etc.
There is a stream and the ground is rock so the water was lying on the surface about an inch deep. Do you think it was just too much for my poor tent and do you think once it has leaked that is it?
In my experience groundsheets dont normally leak unless they are holed. The exception being my Golite nest which isnt designed to be fully waterproof. Most sigs are at least 10000mm HH rated so they shouldnt leak. It is more likely to be coming in from the tent fabric (leaking at seams etc) condensation and dragging water in through footwear.
Try narrowing the problem down by doing things like checking for condensation after a damp night, hose down the tent in the garden to check for leaks, minimise water ingress through doors etc when raining, check if it only happens in high winds and different conditions. Thats a few of my suggestions, hope that helps a wee bit
------------- Jim
Don't forget to leave a review of all tents you've used, for a chance to win fantastic prizes
mmm tricky one, can you describe how the groundsheet looks and feels? As an example my Outwell groundsheets look as if they are made of plastic and dont have that "fabric" look or feel about them. My golite groundsheet looks a bit like tent fabric but thicker but you can see the weave of the material. It could very well be that the groundsheet is not up to the heavy weather you describe?
The groundsheet is some kind of plastic and is anodised apparently to keep the heat in. It is the same kind of groundsheet as my quechua 4.1 pop up if that is any help.
Could it be that it has leaked there due to wear and tear, it is such a great tent that I really want to carry on using it, do you think it would be better to put an extra groundsheet inside or underneath or both maybe?
There are some pics on the tent reviews that show the ground sheet.
Thanks for your help.
Ps. You could be right about the weather the field was seriously wet, we are going to try the elctric hookup field next time because it was slightly further up the hill and looked to drain better. Great site though will be going back but will maybe take a boat next time instead of a tent.
-------------
Don't forget to leave a review of all tents you've used, for a chance to win fantastic prizes
Well I wouldn't write the tent off just yet! If the groundsheet has wear & tear it can be repaired. I strongly suspect that the type of ground you were on (up to an inch of water??) and the fact you had so much rain had a lot to do with your water ingress. If the water couldn't drain away quickly enough some groundsheets will permeate water through with the unlikeliest of things, like for example, the pressure of footfall on them or even water rising so high as to breach the seam between the tent and the groundsheet. A simple solution is having a few old towels to hand!! Sounds flippant I know, but from experience, it works! SIGs have a habit of making a small amount of water look like a lot!
Thanks Jim, that is a great idea. I think you are right, I think it was just the weight of us going in and out.
We could maybe put the porch on the other side sometimes and wear that side out as well.
I feel a bit daft now knowing that we could have just wiped up the water and carried on but I was on my own with 4 kids so I thought I should abandon camp.
We love the tent and although we realise that it wont last forever it suits our needs perfectly at the moment, so extra towels it is then.
If you are pitched in a river what do you expect? It's not a boat.
Water can seep through groundsheets especially if used in standing water. I think you answered your own question when you asked if it was just too much for your poor tent. I am not a lover of footprints for that reason...water can seep between the footprint and groundsheet and then you find yourself pitched in a lake.
Under normal conditions rain soaks into the ground underneath a tent, or it doesn't get underneath in the first place and the groundsheet is waterproof enough, but in really adverse conditions such as you describe you are asking a lot of your tent.
Don't forget to leave a review of all tents you've used, for a chance to win fantastic prizes
Just another perspective - I have 2 lightweight Vango tents that as they got older the SIGs became porous. As I had not used a footprint the natural reaction of material and soil is for the material to degrade. A reasonable groundsheet should let in ABSOLUTELY no water unless it is damaged or the water comes in another way.
If the SIG is old and porous I think you can't do too much about it. A footprint, polythene sheet or as I use closed cell foam from under laminate flooring will stop water coming in from wet ground but it will not protect you if you have a flood and the water gets between the footprint and the SIG.
Hope you sort it
-------------
"The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt." - Bertrand Russell