Having just bought a Montana, we're now starting to put together proper camping kit. We've always camped, but just in a small tent with an airbed, and maybe just a night or two usually. Hear a lot of talk re these mattresses but they are very expensive. Tesco have ones for £15, has anyone used them? Are they any good? Wary of spending a lot of money on a self infating mattress if it's not for me.
I think it's down to personal preference on whether you want to be higher off the floor or not, personally i prefer being higher, but was considering buying a self inflating one as they do seem to get good reviews. So we went to a camping shop yesterday, they had one up inside a tent so i laid down on it lol, pleased i did because i didnt like it so i will be sticking to airbeds, but as i said thats my preference, you might love them as a lot do.
Jak
------------- www.classyballoons.co.uk
'often imitated never copied'
Thwe Teson one looks ok, it's an Intex branded one it says. however, one big proviso.
It is only 2.5 cm thick. this is the sort of thickness that people use on the ones that they take backpacking etc. (though this mat is bigger and heavier ).
I have a 3/4 lengtyh Thermarest of this thickness, and whiles it's is comofrtable enough, that thickness is a bit of a compromise to keep the weight down. Some people certainly wouldn't find it comfortable enough. I'm happy with it, but I prefer a bit more thickness
For more general use i'd recommend people looking at least at a mat of say 3.5 cm thickness. We have a couple of those thickness i think and they are noticebly more comfortable - I use one as my general camping mat.
I tried one of the thin self-inflating mats and at first thought it was great. Seemed warmer than an airbed and takes up little room (doesn't matter if you step on it). However, I eventually decided mine was a little uncomfortable because it was too thin and felt as if I was sleeping on the hard ground. I gather the thicker mats (fat airics etc) are much better but well beyond what my income can afford. I have now gone back to an airbed and bought a double height one which feels like luxury after years of restless nights sleeping on thin airbeds and then a thin mat.
My son bought an excellent, if bulky, sleeping bag and some of our DofE kids bought excellent rucksacks from Tescos last year, all really cheap so in all probabillity the self inflating mat will be good. Anyway, for £15 you've got nothing to lose have you?
As regards the thickness of the mat, what you sleep on at home is a good indication. I sleep on a hard "Dunlopillo" mattress and prefer to sit on the floor because it's bettter for my dodgy back. I have a thin Thermorest "Pro-lite" for backpacking and I'm perfectly warm and comfy on it but if you're used to a soft mattress, it really wouldn't do for you.
I hate airbeds because they're cold, squidgy and i don't like the smell.
The thinner cheap self-inflating mats are fine for kids. As you get older, heavier and creakier though you either need one of the thick cheap ones (like the ones from Aldi) which don't roll up very well, or grit your teeth and go straight for something like a thick Thermorest or Fat Airic.
Whatever you buy though, a self inflating mat will always be warmer to sleep on than an airbed, unless you insulate the airbed well.
the ones in costco...£17.70 are 7.5cm thick and although not the greatest quality they are very comfy(more so than my 5cm thick gelert ones that cost more than double that)
well worth the effort of finding someone with a Costco card thingy...
Quote: Originally posted by valbarley on 17/4/2010
Do the self inflating matresses ever actually get any smaller when you roll them up though?
They always seem pretty bulky for packing
have to say i was in tears rolling up the costco one...its very thick AND wide so i ended up sort of straddling it in an extremely un-ladylike fashion..eventually some bright spark told me to roll as tightly as pos with the valve open then quickly fasten the valve ,unroll it ,then roll again releasing the rest of the air right at the end...and it did make it about the same size as it was when 'virgin'...unlike the rest of my kit which seems to explode once it has been unwrapped from it's original packaging..
For longer trip we use thicker (7.5cm) but do have thinner thermarests for backpacking
I find this works well for packing away. Open the valves, fold the mat in thirds and sit on it. When most of the air is out close the valves and then roll the mat, opening the valves as required to expel the remainder of the air.
Bought 2 from Aldi last summer, inflate to 5 cm & are excellent. Much more comfy the the inflatable mattress & a shed load warmer. Plus only paid £12 for each.
I don't know for sure but I suspect that a lot of cheaper generic self-inflating mats (Karrimor, Gelert, and those sold in supermarkets) are made in China by the same manufacturers. I use a 3/4 Karrimor one for summer wild camping that I paid £15 for. There's no real difference between that and my Slim Airic. The 3/4 mat is thinner by design, but the valves and construction look the same, material similar.
Certainly I'd go for a cheaper mat if you just want to try it out. I still have one I bought to try from Argos about 8 years ago and it still works. Different design and a bit heavy which is why I tend not to use it often.
Quote: Originally posted by weetabixface on 17/4/2010
For longer trip we use thicker (7.5cm) but do have thinner thermarests for backpacking
I find this works well for packing away. Open the valves, fold the mat in thirds and sit on it. When most of the air is out close the valves and then roll the mat, opening the valves as required to expel the remainder of the air.
W
i'm liking that idea...sounds slightly more elegant than straddling and rolling on the beast...
will try it soon as i am off to pickering on monday..just off to look at the weather forecast...