From experience of a very muddy field at Bruce's Cave a couple of years ago, a motor mover works very well, as long as you reverse the van; I didn't even try going forwards as I was (and am) convinced that the jockey wheel would dig in (being narrower and smaller)....
I wouldn't like to try with the car attached at the same time....
Gram
------------- What's the difference between a chicken?
Quote: Originally posted by wizard9956 on 04/8/2011
I can see a small problem with the mover idea , if the car doesn't move as quick as the mover even by a small amount the mover will end up applying the vans brakes .
atb
Wizard
I was thinking the same thing, but would be ok going backwards. If you unhitched the caravan then there would probably be sufficient traction to free both separately.
Discounted Insurance Quotes for UKCampsite.co.uk visitors! Up to 12.5% off!
There are limits to the amount of traction you can get from rubber tyres even using assistance of mover. The next step up is a tractor and then tracked vehicles or winches.
Quote: Originally posted by Moon Chaser on 04/8/2011
I would just like to give a tip to caravanner's.<P style="MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0cm">A friend of mine told me that he got stuck in a wet field so I ask him how he got out, like hours later! I asked him if he used his van mover?, then you could see the penny dropped.<P style="MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0cm">When you lose traction STOP ! engage van mover sit in car and operate both car and mover at the same time, hence 6x6 (if your a 4x4) or 4x6 if not, take it slow and easy and you will get out.( NO REVING and NO WHEEL SPIN. KEEP front steering wheel's straight till moving.<P style="MARGIN-BOTTOM: 0cm">enjoy
Not a good idea at all in my opinion. If the caravan suddenly breaks free you are risking stripping the egars in the motor mover. We saw it happen on a site. If the tyres are muddy the motor mover more than likely will slip on the wheels and be of no use anyway. I certainly woudl not even consider it even though others may be willing to take the chance.
Quote: Originally posted by Moon Chaser on 06/8/2011
Hi, "rather go for hardstandings"
Some of the prices that Iv been quoted per night is off this planet, so I go to "CL" sites if there is one in the visiting location.
BY THE WAY I will be going to "Tewkesbury" in September if anyone can point me to a "CL" site close by I'll be greatfull.
There is another trick/tip thats up my sleeve.........to get you out of the field.................?
Can I suggest that you try the CC site at Ripple. It also has a shower and toilets. Failing that you could always go here Latter comes highly recommended. Good food, fishing etc. We will be down there in Septemeber sometime. if they are full try The Willows caravan Park. Here is a link to the page. On the same site different area.
Quote: Originally posted by brianconwy on 06/8/2011
There are limits to the amount of traction you can get from rubber tyres even using assistance of mover. The next step up is a tractor and then tracked vehicles or winches.
In wet weather I'd rather go for hardstandings.
Very true - I usually find once I get in a muddy morass up to the axles, it's time to start winching - fortunately I never have the caravan on the back at the time.
For some reason some caravan owners seem to think that the best way of getting off a wet grass pitch is the 'pedal to the metal' approach no matter what car they drive - all this with standard road tyres of course.
As for the OP's idea... you should never use two different methods of propulsion at the same time i.e winch only, never winch and engine, as for a motor mover... you'll be trying to push your car with 2 windscreen wiper motors - have a feeling the warranty won't quite cover a burnt out motor in this situation...
Best way of doing this is to get your car on solid ground and then get your van off using the mover (if you have one of course)
------------- Caravanning is a way of getting a cheap holiday out of an expensive hobby
Despite using my van 12 months of the year, and most of the time on CS I have only needed assistance off a feild twice.
Once (wish I could find the pic on here) was a meet, threw it down all weekend, and pitched at the bottom of a feild, a motorhome needed a COUPLE of 4x4s to pull it out,
The second my van had sunk into the ground over the 2 weeks we were there by a couple of inch.
I am usually able to get off a pitch without digging it up, and without a 4x4, wet to not...
Quote: Originally posted by timtheenchanter on 06/8/2011
Despite using my van 12 months of the year, and most of the time on CS I have only needed assistance off a feild twice.
Once (wish I could find the pic on here) was a meet, threw it down all weekend, and pitched at the bottom of a feild, a motorhome needed a COUPLE of 4x4s to pull it out, The second my van had sunk into the ground over the 2 weeks we were there by a couple of inch.
I am usually able to get off a pitch without digging it up, and without a 4x4, wet to not...
I want one! Not only useful for caravan sites, but you could also go for a cruise on the lake or down the canal, save on ferry or eurotunnel charges when going abroad....
Gram
------------- What's the difference between a chicken?
The old way to get off a muddy pitch, even before motor movers were invented, was to carry a tow rope long enough to tie to your tow ball and around the caravans hitch once the Car was on firmer ground, then it was 2nd gear to get more traction and as much weight as you could load onto the driving wheels of the car, I regularly used to sit my teenage daughter on mine or OH's Knee on the front seat whilst manouvering off a sticky patch of land with a front wheel drive car. We used to rally a lot with our last caravan, and i had the technique so fine tuned that I often helped get other units off the rally field. then more by fashion than need lol we bought a 4x4, with that i was able to just tie the tow rope to the front winching eyes on the car being towed and tow off the whole lot in one go.
These days i must admit that im a bit soft and tend to stick to hardstanding pitches, but these are not without their problems when they kick up gravel into the movers casing which has to be painstakingly removed with a pair of long nose anglers forceps.
Julia
------------- Just love to be out amoungst Nature and Wildlife
Celebrating 37 years of Caravanning in 2019, Recently Considered Retiring, but Totally Addicted for Life!