Home

   Log in or Register



Insurance Quotes
forums Campsite Search Comp Directory tips virtual brochure Profile
Tent and Awning Reviews Competitions Caravans and Motorhomes For Sale Shopping Diary Advent Calendar

Advertisement

Message Forums

Welcome Guest Register Login Search The Forum Posts Since Last Visit
 Reception - All Forums
  Caravans and Caravanning
Share   Post on X / Twitter  Share on Facebook  Email  Printer Friendly Version Print
Subject Topic: Towing Vehicle or `Van? Post Reply Post New Topic
01/4/2011 at 9:20am
 Location: Cornwall
 Outfit:  Hobby 650 Ec low profile motorhome
View emmitdb's Profile View Profile   Reply to emmitdb Reply   Quote emmitdb Quote  
Joined: 28/7/2004

Platinum Member
Platinum Member

Forum Posts:   1177

Site Reviews Total: 9
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 1  
Site Reviews 2018: 1  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 9
Site Nights 2018: 1

Greetings,

I have a question out there for any techically minded folk.

Assuming that no loads are exceeded and that both vehicles are loaded correctly (with a correct noseweight, correctly distributed in the 'van), which gives the better ecomomy?

A light car and a heavy van, (where, for instance, the awning et al is in the van) or the other way around, A heavy car and a light 'van. (Where the awning and gubbins is in the car.)

Anybody out there know the answer.

 

 

 



-------------
How come when some people visit the fountain of knowledge, they only gargle!!!


01/4/2011 at 10:11am
 Location: 
 Outfit: 
View Angus1215's Profile View Profile   Reply to Angus1215 Reply   Quote Angus1215 Quote  
Joined: 26/8/2008

Platinum Member
Platinum Member

Forum Posts:   650

Site Reviews Total: 5
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 0  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 0
Site Nights 2018: 0

Shouldn`t make any difference at all.

You are still having to move a given weight, and your aerodynamic profile will also remain unchanged.

The only thing which may change is your stability.


Discounted Insurance Quotes for UKCampsite.co.uk visitors! Up to 12.5% off!
UKCampsite.co.uk users are rewarded with up to 12.5% off Caravan Guard touring caravan insurance, folding camper and trailer tent insurance, and 5% off motorhome and campervan insurance. Static caravan insurance is also available. Get an online quote now

01/4/2011 at 10:26am
 Location: yorkshire
 Outfit: MG zt 190 estateBailey ranger 550 6
View Is that all#60mph!!'s Profile View Profile   Reply to Is that all#60mph!! Reply   Quote Is that all#60mph!! Quote  
Joined: 12/3/2010

Silver Member
Silver Member

Forum Posts:   102

Site Reviews Total: 0
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 0  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 0
Site Nights 2018: 0

would go for the heavier car myself,don't want the tail to wag the dog if you get my drift!


01/4/2011 at 12:28pm
 Location: Lancashire
 Outfit: Caravan now Sold
View michael's Profile View Profile   Reply to michael Reply   Quote michael Quote  
Joined: 30/6/2002

Diamond Member
Diamond Member

Forum Posts:   23517

Site Reviews Total: 1
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 0  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 0
Site Nights 2018: 0

should balance out.ie.your van will have a large engine pulling a light load and will be heavy in it self,your light car is pulling a heavy load.diesel engines will give greater MPG but the cost is now higher than petrol and the vehicle will cost more to buy.we only get with our 4x4 petrol 17 MPG with our 3 ltr engine towing at 80%.unless you have owned both combinations i do not think you will know the answer.interesting though.

-------------
the only silly question is the one you do not ask.


01/4/2011 at 6:26pm
 Location: Sussex
 Outfit: 2007 Eriba Triton 430GT
View Crypto's Profile View Profile   Reply to Crypto Reply   Quote Crypto Quote  
Joined: 11/10/2007

Gold Member
Gold Member

Forum Posts:   406

Site Reviews Total: 2
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 1  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 7
Site Nights 2018: 0

I'm with Angus1215, it will make no difference at all.

Your engine has to provide the energy to pull the combined weight of your outfit, it doesn't know where the mass is located, simply has to pull it. Therefore no difference to fuel economy whatsoever.

The question that does arise is "stability" This is definitely affected by the weight distribution between the car and the van.

My own view is that it is better to have the maximum mass in the towing vehicle as long as the the van is properly balanced with the correct tow ball force.

Put it another way. You've never seen a solo car snake because it was overloaded or badly balanced. It might not go round corners very well but will not snake.
However, a badly balanced van will definitely snake.


Advertisement



01/4/2011 at 6:40pm
 Location: West Mids
 Outfit: Swift Ace Statesman & X-Trail 2.0
View G7ACU's Profile View Profile   Reply to G7ACU Reply   Quote G7ACU Quote  
Joined: 22/9/2008

Diamond Member
Diamond Member

Forum Posts:   2617

Site Reviews Total: 11
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 0  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 0
Site Nights 2018: 0

Interesting question but I'd tend to agree with Angus and Crypto makes valid point to.
You ideally don't want to be pulling anything heavier than the car; the ratio isn't just about pulling ability and stability, but ability to stop the thing too.

-------------
Paul

Every day's a school day!


01/4/2011 at 7:18pm
 Location: 
 Outfit: 
View Opensauce's Profile View Profile   Reply to Opensauce Reply   Quote Opensauce Quote  
Joined: 25/1/2010

Diamond Member
Diamond Member

Forum Posts:   4530

Site Reviews Total: 13
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 0  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 0
Site Nights 2018: 0

Makes no difference & only consideration when loading car & van should be best driving trim for whole outfit.


01/4/2011 at 8:04pm
 Location: None Entered
 Outfit: None Entered
View rickyboy's Profile View Profile   Reply to rickyboy Reply   Quote rickyboy Quote  
Joined: 03/8/2010

Standard Member
Standard Member

Forum Posts:   2
Tent Reviews:   1

Site Reviews Total: 3
Site Reviews 2024: 0  
Site Reviews 2023: 0  
Site Reviews 2022: 0  
Site Reviews 2021: 0  
Site Reviews 2020: 0  
Site Reviews 2019: 0  
Site Reviews 2018: 0  
Site Nights 2024: 0
Site Nights 2023: 0
Site Nights 2022: 0
Site Nights 2021: 0
Site Nights 2020: 0
Site Nights 2019: 0
Site Nights 2018: 0

I have a 1999 Citreon Berlingo 1.9 D which is 50mpg  not towing and 40mpg towing. no bother and tows 1200kg weight of caravan easy. It cost me £1400 two years ago - far better than  any 4x4 previously owned.



In order to post a reply you will need to register, or if already registered please log in here

Prev       Next
Quick Links - All Forums - Caravans and Caravanning - Top of Page

Printer Friendly Version Printable version      Share   Post on X / Twitter  Share on Facebook  Email


Latest News, Discounts and Competitions  see all...














9480 Visitors online !

Free UKCampsite.co.uk Window Sticker  -  Recommend to Friend  -  Add a Missing Campsite

[Message Forums]  [Caravan Sites & Camping]  [Company Listings]  [Features / Advice]  [Virtual Brochure]  [Shop!]
[Reception]  [Competitions]  [Caravans & Motorhomes For Sale]  [Event Diary]  [Contact Us]  [Tent Reviews



Please note we are not responsible for the content of external sites & any reviews represent the author's personal view only. Please report any error here. You may view our privacy and cookie policy and terms and conditions here. All copyrights & other intellectual property rights in the design and content of this web site are reserved to the UKCampsite.co.uk © 1999 - 2024


Advertisement


Advertisement


UKCampsite.co.uk
2024 Advent Calendar


Advent Calendar

24 Daily Prizes PLUS a Christmas Day Star Prize worth £999

Request a Reminder