Hi
Could you please explain to me the pro's and cons of propane and butane please .
I've noticed that some people have two has bottles whilst on their travels
Thanks
Hi Stuart , most people will use propane as it has low freezing temperature which means you can use it all year round (without it freezing in the bottle)and it burns hotter than butane .
For this reason I only have propane in my front locker .
Discounted Insurance Quotes for UKCampsite.co.uk visitors! Up to 12.5% off!
Actually, Butane burns hotter than propane and overall, is slightly better than the two. However it behaves differently at colder temperatures (typically below 10 deg C), and fails to perform properly, which is the main disadvantage of butane.
The lightweight gas bottles from Calor are exclusively propane too, so throughout the year, propane is arguably the more convenient choice.
Quote: Originally posted by G7ACU on 12/3/2013
Actually, Butane burns hotter than propane and overall, is slightly better than the two. However it behaves differently at colder temperatures (typically below 10 deg C), and fails to perform properly, which is the main disadvantage of butane.
The lightweight gas bottles from Calor are exclusively propane too, so throughout the year, propane is arguably the more convenient choice.
Have used propane all year round for years, reason being about 25 years ago with our first ever caravan we had butane and it froze, what l did was pour boiling water over the bottle and wrap it in a old sleeping bag it worked for the rest our stay.Also then you had to change regulator to match the correct gas bottle. So now l stick to propane no problem.
------------- You'll Never Walk Alone C'mon you Reds
Quote: Originally posted by TonyDD on 12/3/2013
Have used propane all year round for years, reason being about 25 years ago with our first ever caravan we had butane and it froze, what l did was pour boiling water over the bottle and wrap it in a old sleeping bag it worked for the rest our stay.Also then you had to change regulator to match the correct gas bottle. So now l stick to propane no problem.
same here.
The other thing it, it might start off working, but as the bottle cools as the gas vapourises, it then gets too cold to work (not good in the middle of cooking!!)
We never had any issues with the blue bottles until Feb 2012. A night of minus 10 stopped the gas completely and we had the obligatory two hour wait for the van to warm up on Lecky.
Hence to say we now have the light weight Propane and its been fine.
Same experience as you, Tony B52. Stayed at CC site near Dover a couple of years ago between christmas and new year and was using blue gas bottles. Temperature was around zero by late afternoon and we has oven on for a tasty roast dinner. Oven stopped working so i presumed gas bottle empty so i changed to spare blue gas bottle. It worked fine for about 30 mins then stopped working again. At this point i realised the half cooked dinner was a write-off and salvaged what we could to finish cooking on the single electric hot plate - now that was an interesting juggling game! Discovered temperature overnight had dropped to -8C and the bottle of milk i left in the car froze solid so no tea in the morning. Also discovered that if you put your mind to it you can finish off a tasty roast using just 1 electric hot plate and alot of pan swapping. As soon as blue gas bottles were used up we changed to 1 Calor Lite and 1 small red bottle. Never had gas troubles since. We opted for 1 'old skool' gas bottle and 1 lite because some Calor sellers do not stock lite bottles and didn't want to get caught out!
------------- Why am i doing this instead of camping??!!